Humidity should come from substrate, not misting —
How often have we read of a keeper complaining that they cant get their enclosures to the humidity levels stated on care sheets? Or conversely, a keeper explaining, “I dont know what’s wrong – I have the humidity at the perfect level!”
For keepers with little exposure to reptiles and amphibians in the wild, or to the natural history of their animals, humidity seems to be a setting the keeper tries to achieve in order to be “perfect”. Like setting the thermostat in our houses at 70F – perfect!
We see keepers – some experienced, mostly new – stick a little hygrometer up on the wall of their enclosure where no animal lives and then try to force the humidity up to the care sheet’s recommended levels thru overhead application of water with misting systems or closing off ventilation, or both. Often with disastrous results for the animal.
I recently read a discussion where the “group expert” was explaining to a new ball python keeper that they need to get the cage humidity up to 65%. The new keeper was misting daily and closing down vents to achieve this, while the overhead incandescent was working just as hard to dry the cage down. And of course, the little round hygrometer was stuck up on the side of the cage wall refusing to comply.
This brief exchange teaches a couple important lessons. Without a knowledge of the snake’s natural history, the keeper couldn’t assess the misinformation she was getting from the group expert. And second, its not easy to create high humidity by misting. Light mists of water land on surfaces and quickly evaporate. The result is a brief spike in humidity – not very helpful.
But lets back up. Why would the group expert recommend 65% humidity anyway? Most of the ball / royal pythons we keep as captives come from the Sahel region of Africa, specifically northern Ghana and Togo. The relative humidity in these areas can average 65% for a couple months during the rains, but most of the year it is much lower, and in fact quite arid. (1) And if the animal’s natural history indicates it is adapted to a wide range of humidities, from averages as low as 20% to as high as 65%, why are the experts recommending 65% all the time? What are they missing?
Obviously, the humidity needs of any species changes over time. From hour to hour, day to day and season to season. Aiming for a single “perfect” humidity doesnt make much sense. Using our Python regis as an example, a snake laying in the sun digesting a meal at the entrance to a burrow may be bathed in near infra-red radiation, high UV levels and surrounded by very dry air. It may spend minutes or hours in these conditions, and it may descend into it’s burrow to experience much higher humidity and much lower temperatures. So why are our experts recommending 65% humidity?
Because the keeper doesnt understand the specie’s native environment, and as important, the specie’s behavior within that environment – they can’t interpret the “experts” bad advice.
So now with that in mind we can revisit the question: What sense does it make to try to increase the humidity for a ball python laying out under the warm basking lamp by misting? I hope its obvious now that this strategy is not likely to succeed.
In nature animals know that humidity is found in the ground, or on the ground under cover. Even in tropical areas the animals will experience a range of humidity. One of my first a-ha! moments came while searching for dart frogs (Oophaga) on Isla Popa in Panama. The indigenous guide insisted we could find them but it was hot and sunny, even though it had rained that morning. It was not at all what I imagined dart frog habitat to be like. But of course my guide was right and we discovered a number of them – often sitting in the hot sun! I watched though as they jumped out from under the dried leaves for a moment, then quickly hop back under them, moving from cover to cover while searching for prey, mates or whatever.
Wherever I went in Panama or Costa Rica I found the same thing – the dart frogs often on dry ground, dry forest litter, or up on dry branches and plants. Nowhere did I find the misty, foggy, sopping wet environment I saw in the dart frog hobby – or the tree frog hobby for that matter. Tree frogs were up in dry trees, glass frogs were way up in dry trees, sometimes in sunny, breezy conditions.
I eventually created some vivariums that mimicked the conditions I saw the frogs in in the wild. They worked perfectly. Occasional hand misting and a slightly damp potting mix substrate with a cover of protective leaves provided the frogs with conditions similar to what they would experience in the wild. I thought they were great, but my creations were destroyed by the dart frog community! Many became so angry that they would mount attacks on my social media groups. And of course I was immediately booted from almost all the dart frog discussion groups by the experts who couldn’t bare to witness the travesties I was recommending!
But in both of the examples, the dart frogs and the pythons, we see two important aspects of cage design. One is that humidity comes mostly from below – from the substrate – not so much from the misters above. (Misters are not bad, per se, but they are often used inappropriately. There mere presence of a misting system send many keepers down the wrong path to over watering, and poor humidity management.)
And two, our animals understand that the ground provides the humidity they need. We have to incorporate this understanding when designing cages.
A quick example: A study of cane toads showed that the animals had mental maps of their territory and selectively choose shelters that had the humid conditions they preferred. (2) I have watched my dart frogs, turtles, lizards and snakes do the same. Animals will burrow into substrates or take refuge under surface debris in order to find moisture. Even tree frogs will come down from elevated perches to get under forest litter rather than desiccate in dry conditions aloft.
This is why substrate choice (See: The Great Substrate Debate) and carefully managing the water content of that substrate (See: Managing Substrate Moisture) are two critical aspects of cage design.
1.) https://rmets.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/met.2049
2.) https://www.jstor.org/stable/3892986
- Feeding Garter Snakes – Why so much bad advice?Please feel free to share this to help clear up the confusion around feeding garter snakes! Cutting to the chase: Feed baby garter snakes chopped up night crawlers – adding … Continue reading Feeding Garter Snakes – Why so much bad advice?
- Review of the EcoFlex Mojave 36″ CageOver all this appears to be a good, sturdy cage – at a very low price. I am impressed with its build quality and a couple key features often lacking … Continue reading Review of the EcoFlex Mojave 36″ Cage
- Costs and Links for 4×2 Cage ConstructionIt’s much less expensive to build a nice, but simple 4x2x2 cage than it is to buy one. And depending on which cage you buy, your home made cage may … Continue reading Costs and Links for 4×2 Cage Construction
- Why is Ball Python Care So Abysmal?I recently got kicked out of a big ball python group. I joined out of curiosity and was immediately surprised at 1.) How many BP keepers seemed to want to … Continue reading Why is Ball Python Care So Abysmal?
- The Easy, Fast and Effective Way to Treat Snake MitesThere is a lot of confusion and misinformation about snake mites and how to get rid of them. This 5 minute read will explain the best way to attack the … Continue reading The Easy, Fast and Effective Way to Treat Snake Mites
- Are We Wrong about Humidity Requirements for Emerald Tree Boas and Green Tree Pythons?Debate continues around the humidity requirements of green pythons and emerald tree boas. In part, I think, because there are some misunderstandings about the role of humidity in the snakes’ … Continue reading Are We Wrong about Humidity Requirements for Emerald Tree Boas and Green Tree Pythons?
- Why Hybridize Eastern Indigo Snakes?1. What Are We Protecting?2. The Benefits of Hybridization3. The Fears of Hybridization There is a lot of concern over my plan to produce hybrids from Eastern indigo snakes (Drymarchon … Continue reading Why Hybridize Eastern Indigo Snakes?
- The Herp Hobby 2.0 is Coming … Many are not gonna like it.There is some understandable terror rippling through the herp business these days. The reaction to my last post on the subject made me realize the fear has caused some to … Continue reading The Herp Hobby 2.0 is Coming … Many are not gonna like it.
- Working Groups for Reptile and Amphibian Standards of Care in the US (draft)Introduction The Facebook Page is here for more info:https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61555253836773 In general humans seem to be increasingly concerned over the quality of care we provide our pets. Even improvements for livestock … Continue reading Working Groups for Reptile and Amphibian Standards of Care in the US (draft)
- Shall We Kill Invasive Wildlife?Killing invasive wildlife is almost always a political act, not a biological one. Im annoyed by the people on Reptile ID groups, and elsewhere, that advise people who post pictures … Continue reading Shall We Kill Invasive Wildlife?
- A Nearly Perfect Snake Cage for Nearly No MoneyYou need very little of what is often suggested “` This Guide will walk you thru the simple steps needed to create a nearly perfect snake cage – and explain … Continue reading A Nearly Perfect Snake Cage for Nearly No Money
- The “Diverse Diet” MythThe pursuit of diversity in our pets diet may be doing more harm than good! I decided to write about this topic of diverse (or varied) diets for reptiles – … Continue reading The “Diverse Diet” Myth
- Wild Caught, Big Breeder, Pet Store and Imported Herps?Is it Ethical to Buy Wild Caught or Imported Reptiles and Amphibians? — Catching Wild Reptiles and Amphibians I think its great that there seems to be a trend towards … Continue reading Wild Caught, Big Breeder, Pet Store and Imported Herps?
- Whats Wrong with Tall CagesThe design flaws inherent in tall cages — On the surface it seems like sound advice – arboreal reptiles and amphibians should be provided tall cages. But in most cases, … Continue reading Whats Wrong with Tall Cages
- Poisonous VS VenomousWhy BOTH are often correct — Its become a rather obnoxious trend on social platforms that when ever anyone mentions a poisonous snake, some know-it-all jumps in to correct them. … Continue reading Poisonous VS Venomous
- What’s Wrong with ThermostatsMostly we don’t need them — Most every care sheet you read will instruct you to incorporate a thermostat of some sort into your vivarium design. So maybe its surprising … Continue reading What’s Wrong with Thermostats
- Are Ball Pythons Arboreal?Ball pythons are not a semi-arboreal species, even though they have been found off the ground. — The short answer is no, Python regius, the ball or royal python is … Continue reading Are Ball Pythons Arboreal?
- The SunThe Role of Radiation in Herpetoculture — The sun bathes the earth in heat and light – radiation. Our animals have evolved over millions of years in an intricate dance … Continue reading The Sun
- Nitrogen, Nitrates and NitritesLions and Tigers and Bears, Oh My! —- After a lot of years trying different substrates for herps, I found a good quality potting mix to be simply the best. … Continue reading Nitrogen, Nitrates and Nitrites
- Managing Substrate MoistureA Critically Important and Often Misunderstood Aspect of our Hobby — The substrate in our vivariums has some important duties. But they can not perform these duties if they have … Continue reading Managing Substrate Moisture
- When and How to Use Mist and Rain SystemsMisting and Fogging Systems are Often Misused — There is a place for overhead precipitation systems in herpetoculture – fog, rain or mist – but they are not common. The … Continue reading When and How to Use Mist and Rain Systems
- Why Drainage Layers SuckThere is almost never a good reason to use them — I dont think there is any aspect of modern herpetoculture quite as ridiculous as the drainage layer. Incorporating a … Continue reading Why Drainage Layers Suck
- The Humidity MysteryHumidity should come from substrate, not misting — How often have we read of a keeper complaining that they cant get their enclosures to the humidity levels stated on care … Continue reading The Humidity Mystery
- Are Clean-up Crews a Waste?CUCs are largely a waste of time and money — I think it will come as something of a shock for some to learn that the whole “Clean-up Crew” thing … Continue reading Are Clean-up Crews a Waste?
- What’s Wrong with Coconut Husk Substrate?These waste products from the coconut industry are not good substrates — There are a lot of different coconut husk products sold as substrate for our enclosures. These are a … Continue reading What’s Wrong with Coconut Husk Substrate?